• Login (enter your user name) and Password
    Please Login. You are NOT Logged in.

    Quick Search:

  • To see new sales and other StampAuctionNetwork news in your Facebook newsfeed then Like us on Facebook!

Login to Use StampAuctionNetwork.
New Member? Click "Register".

StampAuctionNetwork Extended Features

StampAuctionNetwork Channels
 
You are not logged in. Please Login so that we can determine your registration status with this firm. If you have never registered, please register by pressing the [Quick Signup (New to StampAuctionNetwork)] button. Then Login. Listen to Live Audio!

 
logo

The Wagshal Collection Part 4: Perforated One-Cent 1857-60 Issue continued...

Plate Twelve (Quasi Type Ia, Positions 46L12 and 56L12, Scott 18 var., 20, 21)
Lot Sym. Lot Description  
1514 ogbl 1c Blue, Ty. I, Quasi-Type Ia, II, III (18, 18 var, 20, 21).> Positions 34-3644-4654-56L12, block of nine including <Position 46L12, which is the only perforated Type III from any plate other than Plate 4, and Position 56L12, which has the complete1c Blue, Ty. I, Quasi-Type Ia, II, III (18, 18 var, 20, 21). Positions 34-36/44-46/54-56L12, block of nine including Position 46L12, which is the only perforated Type III from any plate other than Plate 4, and Position 56L12, which has the complete design at bottom and partly-erased design at top (an unlisted quasi-Type Ia), the normal relief order for the positions in this block is B-C-C/C-B-B/B-C-C (B=Type II, C=Type I), but 46L12 has a degree of completeness at lower left that is not compatible with the B Relief (see notes below), original gum, few small h.r. mostly where few minor perf separations sensibly reinforced, Position 46L12 shows clear breaks at both top and bottom, 56L12 also has double transfer

FINE-VERY FINE. ONE OF TWO RECORDED 1857 ONE-CENT BLOCKS FROM THE LEFT PANE OF PLATE TWELVE CONTAINING POSITION 46L12 AND THE ONLY ONE WITH 56L12 BELOW. THE PERFORATED TYPE III FROM PLATE TWELVE -- POSITION 46L12 -- IS ONE OF THE GREAT, YET WIDELY OVERLOOKED, RARITIES OF THE 1851-57 ISSUE, AS IS THE UNCATALOGUED QUASI-TYPE Ia PRODUCED BY POSITION 56L12.

According to the Neinken book (p. 495), Position 46L12 is different from all other positions on Plate 12. Given the normal method of entering the positions, it should be a B Relief. However, the bottom left of 46L12 is more complete than it should be if the entry was made from the B Relief. Neinken states that after much study by himself and Elliott Perry, they concluded that it is an exact match for the T Relief used to enter the top row of Plate 11, which was created around the same time as Plate 12. Characteristics of the T Relief include a greater degree of completeness at the bottom left than is present on the B Relief. Neinken theorizes that the siderographer used the T-A-B transfer roll (used for Plate 11), and entered a single position on Plate 12 -- 46L -- perhaps to correct an earlier mistake in entering the position. Other students disagree with the idea that the T Relief was used, and the matter awaits resolution.

Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types. Regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I."

Ex Filstrup. With 1984 P.F. certificate. Scott Catalogue lists Position 46L12 under both Scott 21 and 22 and does not price the former. (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 15,000-20,000

SOLD for $15,500.00
Will close during Public Auction
1515 c 1c Blue, Ty. III and Quasi-Type Ia (2118 var).> Positions 4656L12, vertical pair, <Position 46L12, which is the only perforated Type III from any plate other than Plate 4, and Position 56L12, which has the complete design at bottom and partly-erase1c Blue, Ty. III and Quasi-Type Ia (21/18 var). Positions 46/56L12, vertical pair, Position 46L12, which is the only perforated Type III from any plate other than Plate 4, and Position 56L12, which has the complete design at bottom and partly-erased design at top (an unlisted quasi-Type Ia), the normal relief order for these two positions is B/C, but 46L12 has a degree of completeness at lower left that is not compatible with the B Relief (see notes below), Position 46L12 shows clear breaks at both top and bottom, 56L12 also has double transfer, original gum, h.r., rich color, choice centering for this difficult issue

VERY FINE. ONE OF THREE RECORDED 1857 ONE-CENT ORIGINAL-GUM MULTIPLES FROM THE LEFT PANE OF PLATE TWELVE CONTAINING POSITION 46L12, OF WHICH TWO HAVE 56L12 BELOW. THE PERFORATED TYPE III FROM PLATE TWELVE -- POSITION 46L12 -- IS ONE OF THE GREAT, YET WIDELY OVERLOOKED, RARITIES OF THE 1851-57 ISSUE, AS IS THE UNCATALOGUED QUASI-TYPE Ia PRODUCED BY POSITION 56L12.

According to the Neinken book (p. 495), Position 46L12 is different from all other positions on Plate 12. Given the normal method of entering the positions, it should be a B Relief. However, the bottom left of 46L12 is more complete than it should be if the entry was made from the B Relief. Neinken states that after much study by himself and Elliott Perry, they concluded that it is an exact match for the T Relief used to enter the top row of Plate 11, which was created around the same time as Plate 12. Characteristics of the T Relief include a greater degree of completeness at the bottom left than is present on the B Relief. Neinken theorizes that the siderographer used the T-A-B transfer roll (used for Plate 11), and entered a single position on Plate 12 -- 46L -- perhaps to correct an earlier mistake in entering the position. Other students disagree with the idea that the T Relief was used, and the matter awaits resolution.

Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types. Regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I."

Illustrated in Neinken book on p. 497 (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 7,500-10,000

SOLD for $11,000.00
Will close during Public Auction
1516   1c Blue, Ty. III (21).> Position 46L12, choice centering with perfs well clear of design at top and bottom and with clear breaks in both outer lines, rich color, detailed impression, unobtrusive strike of circular datestamp, faint corner crease at to1c Blue, Ty. III (21). Position 46L12, choice centering with perfs well clear of design at top and bottom and with clear breaks in both outer lines, rich color, detailed impression, unobtrusive strike of circular datestamp, faint corner crease at top right

VERY FINE APPEARANCE. POSITION 46L12 PRODUCED THE ONLY PERFORATED TYPE III ON ANY PLATE OTHER THAN PLATE FOUR. VERY FEW EXAMPLES ARE KNOWN.

According to the Neinken book (p. 495), Position 46L12 is different from all other positions on Plate 12. Given the normal method of entering the positions, it should be a B Relief. However, the bottom left of 46L12 is more complete than it should be if the entry was made from the B Relief. Neinken states that after much study by himself and Elliott Perry, they concluded that it is an exact match for the T Relief used to enter the top row of Plate 11, which was created around the same time as Plate 12. Characteristics of the T Relief include a greater degree of completeness at the bottom left than is present on the B Relief. Neinken theorizes that the siderographer used the T-A-B transfer roll (used for Plate 11), and entered a single position on Plate 12 -- 46L -- perhaps to correct an earlier mistake in entering the position. Other students disagree with the idea that the T Relief was used, and the matter awaits resolution. (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 2,000-3,000

SOLD for $5,000.00
Will close during Public Auction
1517 c 1c Blue, Ty. III (21).> Position 46L12, clear breaks in outer lines at both top and bottom, used with <3c Dull Red, Ty. III (26),> straddle-pane margin and centerline at left, tied by grid cancel and New-York Aug. 16, 1861 circular datestamp on cov1c Blue, Ty. III (21). Position 46L12, clear breaks in outer lines at both top and bottom, used with 3c Dull Red, Ty. III (26), straddle-pane margin and centerline at left, tied by grid cancel and "New-York Aug. 16, 1861" circular datestamp on cover to Lancaster Pa., fresh and attractive

VERY FINE. ONE OF TWO REPORTED COVERS WITH POSITION 46L12, WHICH PRODUCED THE ONLY PERFORATED TYPE III ON ANY PLATE OTHER THAN PLATE FOUR.

According to the Neinken book (p. 495), Position 46L12 is different from all other positions on Plate 12. Given the normal method of entering the positions, it should be a B Relief. However, the bottom left of 46L12 is more complete than it should be if the entry was made from the B Relief. Neinken states that after much study by himself and Elliott Perry, they concluded that it is an exact match for the T Relief used to enter the top row of Plate 11, which was created around the same time as Plate 12. Characteristics of the T Relief include a greater degree of completeness at the bottom left than is present on the B Relief. Neinken theorizes that the siderographer used the T-A-B transfer roll (used for Plate 11), and entered a single position on Plate 12 -- 46L -- perhaps to correct an earlier mistake in entering the position. Other students disagree with the idea that the T Relief was used, and the matter awaits resolution.

Accompanied by 1988 note from William Hatton stating that this example was used as the basis for the listing. (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 2,000-3,000

SOLD for $5,250.00
Will close during Public Auction
1518 og 1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var).> Position 56L12 which shows <complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top,> also a double transfer, original gum, small h.r., bright shade and fresh<><>^FINE. A CHOICE AND RARE ORIGINAL-GUM EX1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var). Position 56L12 which shows complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top, also a double transfer, original gum, small h.r., bright shade and fresh

FINE. A CHOICE AND RARE ORIGINAL-GUM EXAMPLE OF POSITION 56L12, WHICH PRODUCED A DESIGN TYPE THAT DEFIES CURRENT SCOTT CLASSIFICATION -- THE BOTTOM IS COMPLETE, BUT THE TOP IS PARTLY ERASED. WE REFER TO THIS AS A QUASI-TYPE Ia, BECAUSE IT COMES CLOSEST TO TYPE Ia FROM THE BOTTOM OF PLATE FOUR.

Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types. Regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I." (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 1,500-2,000

SOLD for $1,300.00
Will close during Public Auction
1519   1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var).> Position 56L12 which shows <complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top,> also a double transfer, rich color nicely complemented by <red New York City carrier datestamp><><>^VERY FINE. A BEA1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var). Position 56L12 which shows complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top, also a double transfer, rich color nicely complemented by red New York City carrier datestamp

VERY FINE. A BEAUTIFUL USED EXAMPLE OF POSITION 56L12, WHICH PRODUCED A DESIGN TYPE THAT DEFIES CURRENT SCOTT CLASSIFICATION -- THE BOTTOM IS COMPLETE, BUT THE TOP IS PARTLY ERASED. WE REFER TO THIS AS A QUASI-TYPE Ia, BECAUSE IT COMES CLOSEST TO TYPE Ia FROM THE BOTTOM OF PLATE FOUR.

Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types. Regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I." (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 1,000-1,500

SOLD for $2,900.00
Will close during Public Auction
1520   1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var).> Position 56L12 which shows <complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top,> also a double transfer, bright shade, cancelled by double-circle datestamp, Fine, Position 56L12 was discussed in an a1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var). Position 56L12 which shows complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top, also a double transfer, bright shade, cancelled by double-circle datestamp, Fine, Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types, regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I.", with 1986 P.F. certificate (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 750-1,000

SOLD for $2,200.00
Will close during Public Auction
1521   1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var).> Position 56L12 which shows <complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top,> also a double transfer, neat grid cancel, thin spot at center, tear at left, still Very Fine, Position 56L12 was discu1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var). Position 56L12 which shows complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top, also a double transfer, neat grid cancel, thin spot at center, tear at left, still Very Fine, Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types, regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I." (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 500-750

SOLD for $800.00
Will close during Public Auction
1522   1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var).> Position 56L12 which shows <complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top,> also a double transfer, smudged cancel and lightened pen strokes, otherwise Fine, Position 56L12 was discussed in an a1c Blue, Quasi-Type Ia (18 var). Position 56L12 which shows complete design at bottom and erasures of part of the design at top, also a double transfer, smudged cancel and lightened pen strokes, otherwise Fine, Position 56L12 was discussed in an article by Jerome S. Wagshal ("The One Cent Stamp of 1851-57: A Reconsideration of Types I Through IIIa", 1973 Congress Book, pp. 113-115), in which he presented his case for reclassifying some of the 1c 1851-57 types, regarding Position 56L12, Wagshal opined, "[it] requires separate recognition. Its characteristics are unlike those of any other position on any plate of the One Cent stamp. Judged by the standards which are the basis of the One Cent classification system, 56L12 must be given a separate status as a subtype of Type I." (Image)

Search for comparables at SiegelAuctions.com

 E. 300-400

SOLD for $700.00
Will close during Public Auction

Previous Page, Next Page or Return to Table of Contents

StampAuctionCentral and StampAuctionNetwork are
Copyright © 1994-2022 Droege Computing Services, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
Mailing Address: 20 West Colony Place
Suite 120, Durham NC 27705
Back to Top of Page